the Winterking is on you tube

As far as I know Thomas Penn`s next book will be "The Brothers York",to be released in April 2016 on Amazon.Seems a long wait,but if
Mr. Penn needs the time for conscientios research it is worth waiting.
Eva

I, for one, can wait.



________________________________
From: "eva.pitter@..." <eva.pitter@...>
To:
Sent: Sunday, 2 June 2013, 12:55
Subject: the Winterking is on you tube

 

As far as I know Thomas Penn`s next book will be "The Brothers York",to be released in April 2016 on Amazon.Seems a long wait,but if
Mr. Penn needs the time for conscientios research it is worth waiting.
Eva

I can't wait!
Hilary, you are much more patient than I am:D!

Ishita Bandyo
www.ishitabandyo.com
www.facebook.com/ishitabandyofinearts
www.ishitabandyoarts.blogspot.com

On Jun 2, 2013, at 8:38 AM, Hilary Jones <hjnatdat@...> wrote:

> I, for one, can wait.
>
> ________________________________
> From: "eva.pitter@..." <eva.pitter@...>
> To:
> Sent: Sunday, 2 June 2013, 12:55
> Subject: the Winterking is on you tube
>
>
>
> As far as I know Thomas Penn`s next book will be "The Brothers York",to be released in April 2016 on Amazon.Seems a long wait,but if
> Mr. Penn needs the time for conscientios research it is worth waiting.
> Eva
>
>
>
>

Not necessarily. I just want something good!



________________________________
From: Ishita Bandyo <bandyoi@...>
To: "" <>
Sent: Monday, 3 June 2013, 19:00
Subject: Re: the Winterking is on you tube


 

I can't wait!
Hilary, you are much more patient than I am:D!

Ishita Bandyo
www.ishitabandyo.com
www.facebook.com/ishitabandyofinearts
www.ishitabandyoarts.blogspot.com

On Jun 2, 2013, at 8:38 AM, Hilary Jones <mailto:hjnatdat%40yahoo.com> wrote:

> I, for one, can wait.
>
> ________________________________
> From: "mailto:eva.pitter%40ymail.com" <mailto:eva.pitter%40ymail.com>
> To: mailto:%40yahoogroups.com
> Sent: Sunday, 2 June 2013, 12:55
> Subject: the Winterking is on you tube
>
>
>
> As far as I know Thomas Penn`s next book will be "The Brothers York",to be released in April 2016 on Amazon.Seems a long wait,but if
> Mr. Penn needs the time for conscientios research it is worth waiting.
> Eva
>
>
>
>

--- In , "eva.pitter@..." <eva.pitter@...> wrote:
>
> As far as I know Thomas Penn`s next book will be "The Brothers York",to be released in April 2016 on Amazon.Seems a long wait,but if
> Mr. Penn needs the time for conscientios research it is worth waiting.
> Eva
>
Carol responds:

Hi, Eva. Where did you hear about this upcoming book? I can't find a reference to it on Amazon (or anywhere on the Internet), only an acid remark in a long response to a customer review of "The Winter King," in which some opinionated, pompous know-it-all states, "I have absolute contempt for the Brothers York. As I pointed out, the Lancasters may be losers, and the Tudors cheap but neither dynasty devoured their own. The Brothers York are a despicable lot of murderous louts who too often get a pass. The paranoid may indeed have people after him and Shakespeare may indeed have been a hatchet man--that doesn't mean R3 didn't deserve the whacks." He also insists that it's "nonsense" to argue that Richard didn't kill his nephews--exactly the kind of person with whom it's impossible to argue and futile to try,

http://www.amazon.com/review/R30DTGDMM257D9

Carol

I read that review too, Carol. Well, he obviously had the wrong Brothers York, eh? Can't possibly be our lot. It was probably the chap who walked up to me once and asked, in all seriousness, if he could sing me Shenandoah'. I mean, I don't even LOOK like James Stewart!

Sandra


Carol responds:

Hi, Eva. Where did you hear about this upcoming book? I can't find a reference to it on Amazon (or anywhere on the Internet), only an acid remark in a long response to a customer review of "The Winter King," in which some opinionated, pompous know-it-all states, "I have absolute contempt for the Brothers York. As I pointed out, the Lancasters may be losers, and the Tudors cheap but neither dynasty devoured their own. The Brothers York are a despicable lot of murderous louts who too often get a pass. The paranoid may indeed have people after him and Shakespeare may indeed have been a hatchet man--that doesn't mean R3 didn't deserve the whacks." He also insists that it's "nonsense" to argue that Richard didn't kill his nephews--exactly the kind of person with whom it's impossible to argue and futile to try,

http://www.amazon.com/review/R30DTGDMM257D9

Well he seems to think that Richard "personally strangled" Henry VI which says it all as far as I'm concerned.
 
He's probably Alison Weir in disguise.
From: justcarol67 <justcarol67@...>
To:
Sent: Tuesday, 4 June 2013, 0:18
Subject: Re: the Winterking is on you tube

 


--- In mailto:%40yahoogroups.com, "eva.pitter@..." <eva.pitter@...> wrote:
>
> As far as I know Thomas Penn`s next book will be "The Brothers York",to be released in April 2016 on Amazon.Seems a long wait,but if
> Mr. Penn needs the time for conscientios research it is worth waiting.
> Eva
>
Carol responds:

Hi, Eva. Where did you hear about this upcoming book? I can't find a reference to it on Amazon (or anywhere on the Internet), only an acid remark in a long response to a customer review of "The Winter King," in which some opinionated, pompous know-it-all states, "I have absolute contempt for the Brothers York. As I pointed out, the Lancasters may be losers, and the Tudors cheap but neither dynasty devoured their own. The Brothers York are a despicable lot of murderous louts who too often get a pass. The paranoid may indeed have people after him and Shakespeare may indeed have been a hatchet man--that doesn't mean R3 didn't deserve the whacks." He also insists that it's "nonsense" to argue that Richard didn't kill his nephews--exactly the kind of person with whom it's impossible to argue and futile to try,

http://www.amazon.com/review/R30DTGDMM257D9

Carol


Well he's

liz williams wrote:
>
> Well he seems to think that Richard "personally strangled" Henry VI which says it all as far as I'm concerned.
 
> He's probably Alison Weir in disguise.

Carol responds:

He obviously hasn't read any modern biographies or contemporary sources. It requires a strange kind of naivete to take Tudor sources (themselves conflicting) at face value without considering the extreme improbability that the king's eighteen-year-old brother would personally strangle anyone with or without the king's orders. What's sad is that this person seems to be articulate and otherwise intelligent, exactly the sort of person who can convince others too lazy to check the facts that he knows what he's talking about.

Carol

What would it take to make these "scholars" recognize that only a king could order the death of another king (unless it's the Tydder and his mummy pre-Bosworth), and that there's this little thing called "delegate it" wherein the Constable of England doesn't hang, draw, quarter, behead, or strangle anyone personally?

~Weds


--- In , "justcarol67" <justcarol67@...> wrote:
>
>
> liz williams wrote:
> >
> > Well he seems to think that Richard "personally strangled" Henry VI which says it all as far as I'm concerned.
> �
> > He's probably Alison Weir in disguise.
>
> Carol responds:
>
> He obviously hasn't read any modern biographies or contemporary sources. It requires a strange kind of naivete to take Tudor sources (themselves conflicting) at face value without considering the extreme improbability that the king's eighteen-year-old brother would personally strangle anyone with or without the king's orders. What's sad is that this person seems to be articulate and otherwise intelligent, exactly the sort of person who can convince others too lazy to check the facts that he knows what he's talking about.
>
> Carol
>